The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has expressed its concern about Amex GBT’s planned acquisition of CWT.
In a press notice today, the CMA said it is concerned that the merger could lead to “worsened quality of service, higher prices and/or reduced innovation efforts for global multinational business travel customers, as a result of combining the current largest and third-largest company operating in this market”.
“Following the merger, there would be a very small pool of providers capable of catering to the business travel needs of global multinational customers,” it added.
Mike Walker, Chief Economic Advisor at the CMA, said: “We’re concerned this deal between major suppliers of business travel agency services would reduce the pool of providers of these services to global multinational customers, which could lead to worse services and higher prices for global multinational customers.
“It is now up to GBT and CWT to offer solutions to our concerns, otherwise this case will proceed to a more in-depth Phase 2 investigation.”
The press notice said the parties have until August 6 to offer undertakings to the CMA to “address the substantial lessening of competition”.
“If no such undertakings are offered or the CMA decides that any undertaking offered is insufficient to remedy its concerns to the Phase 1 standard, the CMA will refer the merger for an in-depth Phase 2 investigation,” it added.
In the summary of its decision, the CMA said it had concluded that only a handful of TMCs are considered by global multinational customers to be capable of meeting their needs.
“The merged entity (Amex GBT and CWT) would be the clear market leader and the CMA found that the loss of competition between the parties would not be offset by the constraint posed by other suppliers in the market, including other traditional TMCs and more recent technology-driven entrants,” it said.
“In particular, there is only one other TMC for which the evidence consistently demonstrates that it is a good alternative to the parties, while the evidence on the strength of the few other remaining competitors is mixed.”
The CMA said it also considered whether entry or expansion by rival TMCs would be “timely, likely and sufficient” to prevent a substantial lessening of competition arising.
“The CMA considers that the barriers to entry or expansion into providing business travel services to global multinational customers are high. To serve global multinational customers, TMCs need significant scale including a network covering many countries,” it explained.
It said competitors who had responded to the CMA’s investigation stated this is extremely costly and time consuming to achieve.
“Competitors also identified regulatory requirements as barriers to entry and expansion…and also identified experience and track-record as an important factor in their choice of TMC, which recent entrants lack,” said the summary.
“While some tech entrants have succeeded in winning some large customers, their relatively low market shares for supply of business travel agency services to global multinational customers, as well as third-party evidence not identifying them as credible global multinational suppliers, demonstrates the difficulty in entering this space.”
Amex GBT announced its intention to acquire CWT for $570 million in March 2024.
In response to the CMA’s notice, Amex GBT released a statement saying it now expects the deal to close in the first quarter of 2025.
It said it will continue to work with the regulatory authorities to demonstrate how the acquisition of CWT will “create synergies and provide greater capacity for investment and innovation”.
“It will also create more choice for customers and more efficient distribution for suppliers while maintaining a highly competitive environment for business travel services,” said the statement.
Eric J. Bock, Amex GBT’s Chief Legal Officer and Global Head of M&A, added: “We believe that a comprehensive Phase 2 analysis will demonstrate that the proposed transaction would result in many customer and supplier benefits, and that the business travel industry would remain highly competitive.
“In fact, as we’ve seen existing TMCs grow and new tech-led companies enter the industry in recent years, we believe competition will continue to intensify.”
Andrea Caulfield-Smith, Managing Director Global Business Travel of The Advantage Travel Partnership, said: “This news demonstrates the value offered by independent TMCs and the positive impact they can make to the multinational corporate businesses, all delivered without any known impact to prices. Independent TMCs can offer a consultative approach to deliver a personalised and tailored service offering to their customers, something which remains competitive across the travel ecosystem.”




